|
|
Recently Hinn is asking for money to help his minsitry more than any other time before.Lats night he had Steve Munsey (July 18 2003) on asking people to give 77$ under the guideline of the Spirit giving back one hundredfold to everyone. “On June 3, 1999, Mr. Hinn made the surprise announcement that he was relocating his ministry based in Orlando, Fla., to Dallas-Fort Worth because the area offered better accessibility and more opportunities for expansion.” (“What happened to Hinn's promised healing center?” By Steve McGonigle / The Dallas Morning News 6/23/2002). Hinn said: “...most of the ministry's 387 employees would be offered the opportunity to move to Texas, while the 50 people on the church staff would stay as long as the church remained open in Orlando.” The Orlando Sentinel reported a month later on July 7, 1999, “Only 80 of the 387 employees at Benny Hinn's World Outreach Center will be offered new jobs” (www.fakefaithhealers.com). Clint Black then took over the Orlando based church. This began a series of new ventures for the Hinn ministry “At the time, Mr. Hinn was under heavy scrutiny from news media in Florida because of a former ministry security chief's financial corruption allegations against Mr. Hinn. No charges were brought against anyone in that case.”(ibid) Also a drug overdose had occurred inside his organization and “According to Orange County sheriff's records, at the time of his death, Delgado was under suspicion for the heroin-related death of Sydney Williams. Williams, who at one time took care of Hinn's son, Joshua, and later drove a truck for the ministry, died Nov. 15, 1997 at his Florida home after injecting himself with a massive dose of heroin. Delgado was being investigated in the death because Williams appeared to have been drugged following a visit to Delgado's home.” Officials at Hinn's ministry stressed that they had begun random drug testing of employees as a result of the deaths. It declined any knowledge of drug use by Delgado and Williams and issued a statement that, “Benny Hinn Ministries has given many people the opportunity for employment who have rebuilt broken lives through Biblical principles, healing and a new way of life.” Church spokesman David Brokaw told the newspaper, “We will not tolerate and will not condone illegal drug use by employees of the ministry. When we find out about it we will act immediately” (reported by the Quarterly Personal Freedom Outreach, 1999). What is perplexing is that one can look at the videos of Delgado and see that he is on some kind of drug, its hard to believe this would not be noticed by those close to him in Hinn’s organization. Benny Hinn promised several years ago to build a healing center soliciting funds from his followers. http://www.dallasnews.com/dmn/news/stories/062302dnmethinn.39af3.htmlHe proposed a $30 million shrine to faith healing and solicited donations to pay for
it. The ground breaking for that healing center in Dallas Texas was to begin Jan. 3rd
2000. Hinn said God gave him the vision of building a healing center 20 years earlier, but
he began to discuss this project openly, soliciting donations as he began his move to
Texas. The healing center was to be a memorial to faith healers such as Kathryn Kuhlman
and Aimee Semple McPherson, A.A Allen, Jack Coe, Lester Sumerall and Oral Roberts who is
still alive. The facility was to be a place of healing mostly for the supporters of his
ministry and also would be a place “where the sick can come and be healed without Benny
Hinn having to be there” “By August 1999, Cirrus Group, a Dallas real estate developer working for Mr. Hinn,
signed a contract to purchase an undeveloped 8.2-acre lot along State Highway 114, about a
mile northwest of Texas Stadium.” “The popular preacher said he needed to raise $30 million to build this park. He said he needed to raise $5 million by the end of the year, donor cards were distributed with preprinted amounts starting at $1,500. The remaining $25 million was to be raised over two years.”(ibid) The donors would gladly contribute to this spectacular project. $1,500 and you will be reminisced at the Eternal Flame of Healing. $2,000 and your name will be on the rocks in the Healing Stream. $4,000 to $8,000and your name will be engraved on the Fountain of Healings. $15,000 and your name will be on the walls of the Healing Gardens. $30,000 will put your name in the Hall of Faith. $150,000 will put your name on the cornerstone of the People's Cathedral. 3 years later his followers are without the Healing Gardens, statues and waters. Hinn gave a computer-generated tour of the park to a crowd of 17,000 at Reunion Arena on Oct. 29, 1999 in the Reunion Arena, donor cards with preprinted amounts that started at $1,500 were distributed. A live groundbreaking presentation via the Internet was to take place the next day, but it rained. The ministry posted this message on the website: Due to weather conditions, the Groundbreaking had to be postponed. Please watch this website for announcements with the new day and time for the live Internet Broadcast of this event, a later date that never came. “The first sign of a change in plans came from Mr. Brokaw, the spokesman. He told the
Fort Worth Star-Telegram, in a story published Nov. 19, 1999, that the healing center
would not be built in Irving because the ministry's donors wanted a larger parcel of land.” One would think these details would be worked out before you put a down payment and the
time and money starts going into it. Benny Hinn on a Christian telethon a year later: “Many
of our wonderful friends have called and said, ‘What’s with the healing center?’ and
basically what the Lord has said to me is to wait for his voice.”(Dateline) Hinn's “World Healing Center” never materialized even though he claimed to have the word of the Lord on this, Even Rod Parsley a personal friend prophesied it would be the easiest thing he has done. “Despite previous statements by Mr. Hinn and spokesman David Brokaw that the healing center was put on hold because some donors or unnamed Las Colinas interests opposed it, the ministry said in its written response that the decision to delay the project was divinely inspired” The conclusion: “Pastor Hinn felt God had revealed to him in prayer back in February 2000 that the timing was not right for the construction of the healing center portion of the development project in Texas, and he should wait,” the ministry wrote. But this is all after it was stalled because of the various other His ministry has not issue a public accounting of how much money he raised or how it was spent. Those looking into this matter have been told by the ministry that “All funds were used for their designated purpose, or, at the donor's instruction, either returned to the donor or used for an equally important ministry activity consistent with its charitable and religious purpose” (“What happened to Hinn's promised healing center?” By Steve McGonigle / The Dallas Morning News 6/23/2002). “Ole Anthony, the president of Trinity Foundation, a Dallas-based religious watchdog group, said the healing center project struck him from the beginning as “a fund-raising gimmick” (Dateline). “In April 2000, Cirrus Group purchased 6.9 acres along State Highway 121 in Grapevine. Mr. Hinn's ministry began operating the following July in a 58,000-square-foot building Cirrus constructed. “Mr. Hinn, on his television show, asked supporters in October 2001 to provide $7 million to pay for the office building on top of the $2 million that already had been spent. He previously asked them for $1 million to buy office furniture.” (“What happened to Hinn's promised healing center?” By Steve McGonigle / The Dallas Morning News 6/23/2002). Money does not matter In a 1997 television interview, Mr. Hinn maintained that he did not become a preacher to enrich himself. “I don't believe it's right to use your ministry to make money,” he told his interviewer Larry King. “But I do believe [in] making sure your needs are met, and someone like me has needs.” Hinn no longer leases a jet he now owns one. He enjoys luxury cars wears the finest suits. He is seen on television adorned with gold rings, watches and bracelets. He travels around the world staying in expensive hotels that many will never see once in their lifetime, like staying in the presidential suite at the Kahala Mandarin in Hawaii in $3,700-$5,000 a night hotel. But the followers don’t care because he is Mr. Wonderful and can do no wrong, besides he delivers the show. No one seems to notice the dyed or sprayed comb-over hairstyle. (I guess it doesn’t look too good promising healing when one is balding.) Appearances are everything when it comes to TV, every minute spent for TV is edited as the most exciting moments from his crusades to convince his watchers that God’s power is continually there with him.Over the years, Mr. Hinn has made contradictory statements about his wealth. At times, he has said he barely scrapes by, living on royalties from books he has written. At others, he has acknowledged earning at upwards to 1 million a year. “Hinn won’t specify how his ministry’s money is spent, except to say he doesn’t personally benefit from any of it”(Dateline). In his 1997 Honolulu Crusade Hinn made a point about his finances “I have a board of directors. None of whom are my family members, who decide my salary, without my knowledge or permission to be in the board meeting when it's decided.” He then brought one of the board members up to assure the people that what they do is on the up and up. (Benny Hinn's Honolulu Miracle Crusade, Blaisdell Center Friday Night, February 28, 1997). Hinn's organizations revenue has steadily been increasing, from $35 million in 1996 to $50 million in 1997 to a estimated $60 million in donations for 1998. As of 2001-2002 its total ministry revenue now exceeds well over $100 million a year. No one really knows the exact amount. “You know, it’s very sad that the world looks at someone like me and other evangelists and think we’re in this for the money. Do you know what I tell them? They’re crazy! They’re crazy! I can make a lot more money doing something else “(Benny Hinn's Honolulu Miracle Crusade, Blaisdell Center Friday Night, February 28, 1997). Really more than 100 million, I hardly think so! Mr. Hinn's ministry is not required to publicly disclose its finances. Nor does it belong to the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability, a voluntary monitoring organization based in Winchester, Va., that became prominent after the late-1980s scandal involving Jim Bakker's PTL Club. Bob McKeown of Dateline asked Paul Nelson of ECFA: “Is there any way to know how much
Benny Hinn makes? Whether he’s personally benefiting or not, and where the money goes?” We won’t have to wait for his followers to ask for a financial report that he has promised. They don’t care, they are so loyal to this man and under his anointing that nothing of this magnitude matters; except for a few who ask questions because they use critical thinking it all is water under the bridge. The ministry is registered as a church, this makes all the money tax-free and Benny Hinn is under no legal obligation to make his finances public .Hinn’s high lifestyle and his efforts to keep it secret seems to contradict the kind of financial sacrifice he asks of his followers. Yet his cliché “If I had to have a big financial miracle, I would not give a dollar. I would give a big sacrificial seed, believing God for the harvest.” Continues to work for the loyal devotees who believe in his miracles. Hinn can ask “If God would speak to you, even giving $10,000, $50,000, or maybe even a $100,000” (CNN Impact) and they give this amount “some of them pledged or gave more than $100,000 apiece last year (Dateline). Yet he told Impact News (March 16, 1997) when asked what his annual salary was, “Well, John, you knew that that would be private, but ah, I knew you would ask it. I can tell you this, if it wasn’t for my book royalties, I’d be in debt.” “People ask me what I do with this money from my books, for example, from my royalty. I give much of that away … ministries, ah, charities, ah … what comes in through the ministry stays in the ministry.”(Larry King) How can one give away the money if it is going to keep them out of debt? Then in Hawaii at the February 28, 1997 service at Blaisdell Center, Hinn made a complete reversal and discussed the distribution of his books saying, “Anything that sells, I don’t get a cent. All the books, all the tapes, I get nothing. I just get one cent. That’s it!” Well how many books has he sold? His book, Good Morning, Holy Spirit, was on the bestseller list since its release in October, 1990, having sold approximately one-quarter million copies within the first few months. In pennies that would be how much? Do you think this made a difference in his lifestyle, especially since he gives it away? It is highly doubtful a famous figure like Hinn receives this little for his book when others receive much more. His ministry buys his books and then sells them at the crusades. As for his lifestyle, “Hinn explains that some of the perks he has enjoyed like custom-made suits and expensive cars have been paid for by his personal income, including the royalties from his many books”(Dateline). That’s hard to do if “All the books, all the tapes, I get nothing. I just get one cent. That’s it!” “According to the Trinity Foundation, the biggest customer for pastor Benny’s books is pastor Benny’s own ministry. Trinity says the Hinn ministry buys thousands of the books for which Hinn apparently collects the royalties. The ministry then offers them for sale at crusades and on its Web site, and gives them away to donors.”(Dateline Dec.27, 2002) You may need to over this section on the contradictions Hinn has stated where his money comes from because it certainly does not add up. Paul Nelson of ECFA said this “wouldn’t be allowed if Hinn belonged to his organization” (Dateline). With all this said Hinn also says “You know, whenever you see me hold my book up and say, “Go to the bookstore.” I reimburse the ministry for that. I'm very careful with that. When - when - when you see me on the air saying, “Go to the bookstore. Get my book.” They charge me for it. They bill me. They're not too nice to me. But that's just smart. You see. Anything that sells through the ministry I don't get a cent. All the books and all the tapes, you know, I get nothing. I just get one salary, that's it. But the news media and the world are a little crazy when they think we preachers are in this for the money” (Benny Hinn's Honolulu Miracle Crusade, Blaisdell Center Friday Night, February 28, 1997). Certainly having two or three stories of how or where the money goes to does not help present any integrity in this area. Yet there are those like pastor Carlotta Moore “I’m pretty sure NBC’s man that owns NBC probably got his own jet and multimillion dollars,” “Probably got houses here, houses there, and this that and the other. And I believe that the preachers of the gospel, I believe they should live better than even NBC’s president.” While a minister of the gospel should not be poor, I don’t believe there is any biblical justification to be living “the lifestyle of the rich and famous” (though Hinn is both rich and famous). We have examples, just look at the apostles and how they lived, they were right there in the trenches with the people, they did not have mansions on the hill overlooking the ocean and build “the apostle Peter evangelistic center” or “the Apostle Paul healing gardens.” So to compare a minister to a president of one of the alphabet channels is really not the issue. This comparing what is supposed to be spiritual with what the world does with its money, this is not where we should look for justification of this kind of luxurious living. Carlotta Moore told Dateline “she sows a seed of $12,000 a year with pastor Benny, and that she expects to be financially rewarded.” How much does this pastor make to be able give this? this gives you an idea of how much his followers are giving. Dateline reported from those who were inside the Hinn organization of numerous incidents of impropriety with handling sizeable funds. Dateline spoke to a former head usher who said he saw money being taken out of the collection buckets and put in pockets. He was offered one thousand dollars out of the bucket to ignore it, but refused. Several former employees who were interviewed stated that anyone who reported unusual things going on in the ministry was fired. It has become known that one of Hinn's former bodyguards was going to go public about his ministry. The guard was paid a tidy sum of $103,000.00 to be quiet. This looseness of collecting money in ministry we have heard about before. “Hinn employed Licciardello in 1997 to conduct an internal investigation of possible “wrongdoing and corruption concerning the handling of offering money” received by the ministry in the mail and at its international healing crusades. Church officials said the investigator was hired to ensure proper and adequate security measures for the handling of donations.” “During the investigation, Licciardello secured sworn statements from nearly three dozen current and former church employees. Hinn's organization is insisting on the return of the transcribed copies of those testimonies, in addition to any written account of the conversations he had with Hinn and any documents detailing the personal lives of former employees which were compiled by the church.” The Orlando newspaper reported that Hinn had “gone to court to block his former security chief from disclosing financial secrets that an adviser testified could destroy the television ministry.” Mario Licciardello found himself slapped with a federal court gag order to keep from making known information about the financial practices of Hinn's ministry. The newspaper reported that “Licciardello is demanding money to keep him from revealing what he knows about allegations of theft and corruption at Hinn's World Outreach Center” (reported by Personal Freedom Outreach 1999). [ For understanding this point of view from inside by the former members of Hinn’s organization go to Part 2 of the Dateline report-- http://www.msnbc.com/news/848195.asp]Hinn continues to get away with all this right in front of peoples noses but the people love him all the more even though their pockets get more empty as the years go by. The HBO special showed was that Hinn prophesied financial disasters related to Y2K in the horizon and promised “and only those who have been giving to God’s work will be spared” (also shown on Datelines special Dec.27, 2002). Hinn then appealed to the crowd to “increase your faith (which translates in their giving) increase your seed and store up for the future, so that when these tragedies hit on earth you will be spared” (April 15, 2001 HBO broadcast). These disasters never came to those who did not give to his ministry but it works out to his advantage because so many who follow his promises have a short memory span. Benny Hinn: “Every dollar you give this morning is going to the work of the Lord.” Yet on other occasions Hinn has stated most of the money he brings in goes right back into his television show which is broadcast worldwide (CNN Impact). Just a reminder of what he stated “if it wasn’t for my book royalties, I’d be in debt” “what I do with this money from my books, for example, from my royalty. I give much of that away” “the books, all the tapes, I get nothing. I just get one cent” “We pay 90% of the crusades. 90% from the offerings we receive” (Benny Hinn's Honolulu Miracle Crusade, Blaisdell Center Friday Night, February 28, 1997). That leaves only 10%. If Hinn’s ministry takes in 100 million and his salary is 1 million, then where does this money come from? Hmm doesn’t sound right. A parsonage built for Benny The latest report from Dateline news has brought the handling of money in Hinn’s organization more into question than any other report previously, as we learn the details. In 2001 a subsidiary led by Mr. Hinn began work on his over a $3 million
“parsonage” overlooking the Pacific Ocean south of Los Angeles. I never heard of a
mansion called parsonage. The luxurious home he is building in a gated community of Dana
Point, Calif. where other homes are valued between $1 million and $7 million. “Mr. Hinn did not participate in the decision and does not own the property, the ministry wrote in response to a question.” “The owner of the property is listed as Cove Holding Ltd., a partnership formed six days before the Dana Point home site was purchased for $450,000 in August 1997. Mr. Hinn is president of Cove Holding, which lists its address as his attorney's office in Irving.” “Cove Holding is registered with the Internal Revenue Service as a tax-exempt, religious title holding company, meaning that it owns property solely on behalf of a religious parent organization.” “The ministry said the board of directors established Cove Holding to provide a parsonage for Mr. Hinn. Such an arrangement is common among religious organizations.” “The fact that Mr. Hinn is a director or officer of Cove does not disqualify him from receiving benefits,” the ministry wrote (excerpts from “What happened to Hinn's promised healing center?” By Steve McGonigle / The Dallas Morning News 6/23/2002).This may be legal but it certainly brings up the question that if Mr. Hinn is president and director or officer of Cove how does Mr. Hinn not participate in the decision as they have stated? Does my right hand not know what my left hand is doing? But when Bob McKeown of Dateline asked Paul Nelson of ECFA: “Are you aware among your
membership of any church residence, parsonage, that is worth $3 million?” The mansion on the Pacific is considered the Hinn ministry’s church
residence or “parsonage,” and the ministry is picking up all the expenses for land,
construction, even property taxes. Benny Hinn talking about his previously expensive house has said to Paul and Jan Crouch: “The house is my home, I pay for it from my salary. My church does not pay for my home.” He also said in a Charisma interview, “My salary is $116,000 plus a housing allowance.” His Alaqua home at the time was $685,000 and that was not a shabby house, but over 3 million is going to the next level. In an interview to Charisma in August 1993, over flack about his expensive car Benny stated, “But I am replacing it [Mercedes-Benz] with an American-made car, a Lincoln, because I don’t want my lifestyle to cause anyone to stumble.” I guess that doesn’t matter to him anymore. What I find baffling and contradicting is that Hinn stopped preceding on his 30 million
dollar healing center and is unable to even begin his previous commitment for other things
he advertises. Such as “Since February of 2001, the Hinn Web site has been soliciting
donations for a new orphanage to be built in this little town outside Mexico City saying
it would be finished “soon.” Dateline had been trying to get a hold of Hinn for an interview for months. Hinn was finally tracked down outside a hotel after a crusade in Buffalo last year. At least 6 bodyguards immediately rushed to cover the cameras with their hands and tried to scoot Benny away from Bob McKeown the reporter. Hinn apologized for his security and seemed to agree to an interview. Hinn later deprived them of an interview. We need to ask what kind of person needs this many bodyguards everywhere he goes? It reminded me of Jesus who traveled with the disciples, but they weren’t bodyguards, and when they tried to be bodyguards by stopping people from approaching Jesus, He forbid them and allowed ALL to meet him. Could it be that Hinn with all the fame and money he has taken in is concerned or even afraid for his life? What we now need to watch for is Hinn’s spin on TBN so he will not lose any of his faithful followers. This should be interesting. What we now need to watch for is Hinn’s spin on TBN so he will not lose any of his faithful followers. This should be interesting. |
|