What's New
Escaping the Cult
Current Trends
Bible Doctrines
Bible Explanations
Emergent church
Latter Rain
Word Faith
Popular Teachers
Pentecostal Issues
Trinity / Deity
World  Religions
New Age Movement
Book Reviews
Web Directory
Tracts for witnessing
Web Search
The Persecuted Church


For printing  our articles please copy the web page by highlighting  the text first - then click copy in the browser-  paste the article into a word  program on your computer. When the text is transferred into word, click to save or print.      






G12 - The Government of 12  

We all be are for more people coming into the kingdom, it often takes more work than we have people for. However, it is important how people are brought in and just as important how they are trained up. We have seen a lack of discipleship over the years that has resulted in less numbers in the church. 

G12 writes Jesus said, "Make disciples" (See Matthew 28:19-20). He did not just tell us to evangelise or to get decisions. People who accept the gospel and believe must be discipled. They must be taught, shaped and formed into the image of Jesus. The Church often falls short of full obedience in this respect. Many people who make decisions to become Christians are never truly discipled in the paths of Christ. This must change, and we must all place full obedience to Jesus' command on the highest level of our agenda as people and as a church.   

The G12 vision is a practical means by which we can all obey the call of our Master and be a success.

I agree about the lack of discipleship but is G12 the way God gave us to succeed. Is there a way to speed up God's work in an individual? Can everyone have FULL obedience?  The question that needs to be answered is: what is the solution?  Cesar Castellanos of the International Charismatic Mission in Bogota, Colombia  believes God has given him the ultimate solution. I would like to look at what is presented to us as God speaking a new idea to succeed.

(G12) is a cell church model founded by Pastor Cesar Castellanos which is the 400,000 strong (International Charismatic Mission in Bogota, Colombia). Wanting to see growth in his church 'In 1986 He ( Cesar Castellanos) went to Korea and adopted the principles of cell church as taught by Dr Yonggi Cho. By the end of 1991 there were 70 cells. Castellanos cried out to the Lord, “Lord I need something that will accelerate the growth.” And God showed him the missing link - the concept now called G12."

This new model for doing church is also growing elsewhere because a number of well-known people are involved in promoting this new church model of discipleship. In Singapore Lawrence and Nina Khong. England is Colin and Amanda Dye at Kensington Temple. In the United States of America Pr. Dick Bernal Jubilee Christian Center Pr. Larry & Melanie Stockstill at Bethany World Prayer Center and Pr. Ken & Lois Gott.

The G12 system has numerous strict standards. In order to be part of the vision, you are expected to be dedicated, attend your cell group once a week, go to retreats, go out to evangelize, go the Sunday morning service and also attend special meetings with your leader's leader. Each week is surrounded by these church things to do, as your social activities are contained within your cell group. Your week is taken up with these meetings to attend as they make you a more serious disciple.

The school of leaders you are to attend once a week is where you learn doctrine. This lasts twelve weeks (there are three levels in this school.) It has been stated if you miss more than three courses out of twelve (for whatever reason), you must start the course over. At the end you are to have your own cell group, everyone is to become a leader, eventually. We are told “everyone is a potential leader."“ everybody becomes a leader, and in time, runs their own open cell. Everyone is ministered to and everyone becomes a minister” (The Heart of the Vision). You are to save 3 people and become your own group leader and repeat the process all over again. Each person in the cell is to start to build a new cell.When all the members of the original cell have started their own new cell, the original cell becomes a G12 group (G12 Heart of the Vision).

While everyone can disciple people (with or without this model). The problem with multiplication ministries like this is that you may not be ready for leadership and yet they are more than willing to hand over to you 11 other newborns to disciple. Essentially we are told the G12 is NOT about doctrine. It is about a method that they claim is based on the Bible. Their goal -every believer a leader. A leader of what? Of another group of 12. The fact remains, the biblical principle to disciple is a command. The way to disciple that is promoted by G12 is Not a biblical pattern of doing church at all. 

The Bogota G12 model has five stages of implementation called the Ladder of Success: win, consolidate, disciple, send.  After you win someone the second step is to bring them to a retreat for a weekend. Step .2 Consolidate: where they taught on the impact of their past sins, the importance of forgiving those who did you wrong for healing. There are three parts to the Consolidation process.  Consolidation is when the new believer goes through the pre-encounter Bible studies, the weekend residential encounter and the post-encounter called the 'C-Track'. This where they are convinced to follow the G12 model of ministry though we are told four stages are necessary each one is necessary for full obedience to obey the Great Commission . Consolidation process is central to the success of the G12 strategy (Encounters with Jesus Issue 1 - Article 10)

The aim of the Encounter is total transformation that will give birth to the character of Christ in the believer. It is a preparation for the training that takes place at the School of Leaders. Encounter deals with the following subjects and issues in depth: Repentance -Forgiveness -Breaking of Curses - Deliverance - Inner Healing - Baptism with Water-Baptism with the Holy Spirit -The G12 Vision.

In the courses they put in practice what they call “spiritual warfare,”  they break Generational curses to make the new disciple ready.  So many of the new Charismatic trends seem to have found their way into this G12 model. It has been reported people throw up demons for deliverance (Is there a better way to get rid of them?)  Some time is spent on breaking “generational curses” you get all the bad stuff out of them you do that through pre-encounter, a 6 week class that teaches you the basics of christianity and then the encounter, where you pretty much break whatever is holding you back from going all out for God. Then Post-encounter which teaches you how to stay in the victory you gained at the Encounter.
3 Disciple: you teach the people how to become a leader, you talk to them about evangelism, courtship, abundant life, etc. These classes are ten weeks long and you do these by going to School of Leaders 1, 2, and,3
4 Send: By now you are a cell leader and building your 12 disciples that you must intercess for. Then you are sent out to missions get your 12 lead a cell group etc.

The Pre-Encounter, the Encounter and the Post-Encounter are necessary because “Often believers today have never been truly consolidated in their faith as experienced in the G12 structure. This means many issues dealt with at the Encounter are still unresolved in their lives. Sadly, they carry pain, bondage and demonic curses for many years and still need to be set free in some areas of their lives.

After one after another of this rigorous training you are convinced, fired up and ready to go. Churches who willingly become part of the G12 are expected to fully be committed and not attend elsewhere. Those who become part of G-12 hold to God anointing ICM in a special way and are willing to submit to ICM's (International Charismatic Mission) covering. Submission to your authority (leader) comes naturally once you have accepted the vision.  I have received many letters that say basically the same thing: people have been accused of things they have not done and told that if you don't support the vision then you won't grow in God. This manipulation seems to be inherent to the G-12 model.

Some churches follow the G-12 model in the way it was invented, others extract portions they like out of it and use it. Others believe it must be used the way it was given for the results, the founder seems to hold to this position. When submitting to follow the G-12 system in its entirety covenant relationship with ICM is made. Become part of the ICM network of churches, which normally requires multiple trips to Bogota each year. It has been reported recently, ICM has asked people to sign a written agreement to follow ICM's system exactly. This written agreement allows churches to use ICM's material. The training includes: Pre-encounter- Encounter Retreat - Post-encounter- School of Leaders.

Larry Stockstill writes in his book “The Cell Church” “A paradigm controls how we interpret what we see and experience. It consists of a whole set of perspective shifts, which usually require effort and a stretch to perceive things differently, leading to a paradigm-shift” (The Cell Church; Larry Stockstill; Regal Books; Ventura, California, 1998, p.30)

The paradigm shift has become a familiar term for bringing people into a new way of doing things. In the churches case, it has been taking us away from doing it biblically into new revelations that lead us in doing today’s church. They say this is not a new revelation, but we can’t take their word on it, we need to look at the Scripture to see if their practice match's it.

Here is how its done. for one to enter the new paradigm they must let go of the old according to the new age movement. This same principle is applied in G12. the founder Cesar Castellanos addresses developing the vision by giving an example of a pastor and an architect. With the same argument used of not pouring new wine into old wineskin, the pastor come to the architect and “wants to keep some of the old structure because it some good and valuable parts, although they have been severely weakened.” The architect replies that it cannot be done. His life dreams, desires and hopes are connected to the old building. The architect insists, “It is not possible to build the new house and keep the old structures. You must choose which one you want.” And the man answers, “I will look for another architect for advice.”

Some have tried something similar when they seek to establish the G12 vision but we know that it cannot work this way. The old structure was good, it worked and it served its purpose, but if you want to multiply, you cannot hold on to it. The Holy Spirit will give new foundations for great growth.

We have heard from pastors who had worked for years building their ministry. They arrived at a point where they could not advance any more and realised that they needed a change and supernatural intervention. They had to demolish the old building to make space for the new with the G12 vision as the foundations. Because they took this step their ministries have seen multiplication like never before.

Consider what is being presented. If your church was built on the true foundation and doing things Biblically, would it be necessary to abandon it for the new G12 model? Since many have not built on biblical ways they are open for the next wave of spiritual pragmaticism.

Is growth in numbers more important than growth in spiritual maturity? This seems to be the case with all the new trends that have bought into  we are going to take the world for Christ philosophy. There is an old concept that seems to have stuck with me because it's true. Healthy sheep produce sheep. In other words if people are really being taught the word and seeing the power of God changing their lives they can't help but go out and share it with others.

His G12 teams are “to share with you the secrets of the vision God has entrusted to us.” “It is now time for that vision to run throughout the earth. It is my desire and fervent prayer that God will bless you and release in you the power of this vision …”( Pastor Cesar Castellanos, First Word)

He calls it secrets of growth that God gave to him by a vision. He writes in How did Jesus do it?  “I began to see Jesus' ministry with clarity. The multitudes followed, but He didn't train the multitudes. He only trained 12, and everything he did with the multitudes was to teach the 12. Then the Lord asked me another question: “If Jesus trained 12, should you win more than 12 or less than 12?” 1. Jesus chose 12 to reach the multitudes. 2. He stayed with these 12 permanently, until they were trained and He released them, gave them authority and empowered them to disciple the nations. 3. The call is to find the 12 and to reproduce Christ's character in them.

Did Jesus  only train 12, are we to look for only 12? These are questions that need to be answered because his whole vision is based on this number 12.

Here is how he explains it is accomplished “You need to pray so that God reveals your twelve to you. Jesus won His twelve through a night of prayer. But His twelve didn’t belong to Him; they belonged to the Father. Jesus confirmed this in his prayer (John 17:9) “I do not pray for the world but for those whom You have given me, for they are Yours.” Your twelve belong to the Father, but when you pray, God reveals your twelve to you.

When you receive your twelve in your spirit, you will feel like a pregnant woman. First the child is conceived by faith and then it will be born” (Step one: Conceive the Group of 12 by Faith)

So we have a pattern that is claimed to be biblical and to be followed by praying. I need to emphasize we have no record of any apostle or anyone in the church praying for 12 disciples to be under them to start the process over.

Number 12, Number 12, Number 12 

The cell concept is based on the number twelve which is a significant number in the Bible. They claim “it’s not the only number that carries great weight in the Bible. There were three disciples who had special intimacy with Jesus, Jesus was raised up on the third day, and there were three crosses at Calvary. God created the heavens and earth in seven days, the sabbatical year occurred every seven years.”

The Scripture does have certain numbers that are given greater importance, the number 7,12, 40,70 are repeated. However what must be answered is if the numbers are used biblically; is the number 12 taught to the church by the apostles? Though they recognize other significant numbers from the Bible, their literature  promotes the number twelve as God's special “anointed” number (reference: Rocky Malloy's The Jesus System: Groups of Twelve, Pastor César Castellanos' books Leadership of Success through the Group of 12 and The Ladder of Success)

Here are some examples: Castellanos states “The model of 12 has always been in God's heart. The number 12 symbolises government. At creation God established 12 months to govern each year; even days are governed by periods of 12 hours each. To govern the people of Israel, God established 12 tribes and King Solomon appointed 12 governors.

“In 1991, the lord removed the veil from my mind and gave me a deep revelation about the meaning of 12. I had asked myself why Jesus taught 12 and not 11 or 13. I also thought, the larger the number, the faster the work would progress. Why did Jesus invest His effort in just 12 people? Then I heard the voice of the Holy Spirit deep in my heart. He said if I trained 12 people, reproducing in them the character of Christ in me, and each of them did the same with another 12 - the continuation of the process, with every group of 12 transferring what they receive, would lead to unprecedented growth in the church (Adapted from 'Successful leadership through Groups of 12' by Pastor Cesar Castellanos)

Wait a second Jesus had 12 but one apostasized. This is not included in his equation, that would make 11. Acts 1:21-25 “Therefore, of these men who have accompanied us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,” beginning from the baptism of John to that day when He was taken up from us, one of these must become a witness with us of His resurrection.” And they proposed two: Joseph called Barsabas, who was surnamed Justus, and Matthias. And they prayed and said, “You, O Lord, who know the hearts of all, show which of these two You have chosen “to take part in this ministry and apostleship from which Judas by transgression fell, that he might go to his own place.”

The original 12 had one less because of betrayal which had to be replaced. The fact is, the apostles chose one more to replace  Judas, Mattias became number 12. He was not one of the original 12, he came from the 70. This seems to bring the whole concept of 12 tumbling to the ground since it is supposed to be from only the 12 Jesus specifically trained. In fact the two   that were the choice to replace Judas (Barsabas and Mattias) are both outside the 12.

An then what of Paul, he was 13 was he not? (depending on if you count Judas, this would make him 14 after Mattias). He was not trained with the group of twelve that was trained by Jesus when he was physically on earth. Paul who was not of the 12 wrote the majority of the epistles in the New Testament. How does this fit with his vision model of 12. How does this work with what Castellannos claims God spoke to him about 12. It doesn’t! 

Furthermore Castellannos makes a unproven claim and attributes it to the Holy Spirit  and each of them did the same with another 12 - the continuation of the process, with every group of 12 transferring what they receive.

Where did the 12 apostles (14 actually) pick 12 as the number? This is not found in Scripture.

On the topic of “Shape your group of twelve,” the founder Cesar Castellanos writes “In the spiritual realm it is the group of 12 that gives us authority, government and maturity in its fullness. The group of twelve has a special significance, that is why we read about the twelve tribes of Israel and the twelve apostles. You must help your disciples to have their own group of twelve (Pastor Cesar Castellanos in his article Effective Leadership)

You don’t find the apostles diligently looking for twelve disciples in order to repeat Jesus’ pattern of twelve disciples. No other apostle had a group of twelve, only Jesus did. Nowhere does the Bible instruct us to repeat a number pattern like this so we can have authority or maturity in the spiritual realm. If the apostles did not try to copy Jesus in this numbering why is there a vision with this number today? The12 were apostles that the Lord handpicked, it was never made a model for the church to continue so we can succeed. Paul being picked afterwards proves this.

 Colin Dye who is also involved in this movement says “A primary leader that surrounds himself with 12 and then one of the 12 becomes a primary leader.” This is their multiplication method, to meet in a group of 12 and disciple others. There is no biblical number that is more powerful or more anointed than any other. Yet the founder says the spiritual realm will recognizes the number 12, so you must continue with this number. This sounds like the Mormon church having 12 apostles and new prophets for the continuance of the church than a bible concept given by the apostles.

Steps to Establishing a Group of 12 by Sarah Ajayi “The Establishment of the government of 12 OF 12 Teaching about Elijah in 1 Kings 18:30 -35, Cesar Castellanos taught the delegates on ‘Steps to ensure the vision’. Elijah symbolically restored the Government of 12 when he placed twelve stones around the altar of sacrifice. The Government of 12 provides protection for the leaders and disciples. We need to restore the altar of God by moving closer to Him and operating in His authority. The anointing in the vision is needed to get through to the people. Like Elijah, Christians need to confront the apostasy in society.

Twelve stones are the government restored symbolically? The Government of 12 provides protection for the leaders and disciples. Did the Church not have protection until G12 came along? I think they are making a number more powerful than the Spirit. The 12 stones were placed symbolic to the tribes of Israel, they were not a government.  The stones represented the nation to their enemy, the prophets of Baal in Elijah's encounter, as he proved Israel's Lord (Yahweh) was truly God. 

Another questionable statement that needs to be addressed is the churches call, to confront apostasy in society? How about the apostasy in the church as the Bible teaches. The society cannot apostasize from what they never held, they never knew or practiced the truth.. Only those who leave the faith apostasize, this is not a realistic view or mandate for the church.

G12 insists there is always 12 “Then He appointed twelve, that they might be with Him and that He might send them out to preach and to have power to heal sicknesses and cast out demons” (Mark 3:14-15). (G12 What is a Cell? www.kt.org

On the topic The Secret is in the Twelve- One of the first things I learnt from the Lord at this time was that to implement the model of 12 one must walk in supernatural power, casting out demons and performing miracles according to each person's need.

Hold on a second, at this time Jesus also gave this same authority to 70 as well, not just 12, and they were ALL disciples. Later the 12 became apostles, there is a difference.

Luke 10:1-2 “After these things the Lord appointed seventy others also, and sent them two by two before His face into every city and place where He Himself was about to go. Then He said to them, “The harvest truly is” great, but the laborers are few; therefore pray the Lord of the harvest to send out laborers into His harvest.” V.17 “Then the seventy returned with joy, saying, “Lord, even the demons are subject to us in Your name.” v.19  “Behold, I give you the authority to trample on serpents and scorpions, and over all the power of the enemy, and nothing shall by any means hurt you.”

Some may say does this number 12 matter as long as it works? It does to the founder. I'm proposing that you can take any number of people and train them in this manner to have a repeat process, but he is saying God told him it must be 12.

Yet we do have another example of the apostles picking people to replace their work and the number is 7 not 12.   “Then the twelve summoned the multitude of the disciples and said, “It is not desirable that we should leave the word of God and serve tables. “Therefore, brethren, seek out from among you seven men of good reputation, full of the Holy Spirit and wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business; “but we will give ourselves continually to prayer and to the ministry of the word ”(Acts 6:2-4).

The concept of the number12  is not always there, why did the apostles choose 7 to work for them? (this may lead to G7) but the fact remains that apostles did not see 12 as the number for successful discipleship.

In their topic “Master the vision” “The Lord told Abraham to set his eyes and look to the land he was going to possess. God is entrusting you with the redemption of your nation. You decide if you dare to achieve it. But remember, you are irreplaceable, if you don’t do it, there is no one that will take your place. Take a new breath, believe that you are going to achieve, decide to believe in God and breakthrough towards victory! (Pastor Cesar Castellanos in his article Effective Leadership)

Wow, imagine having this weight on your shoulders, you’re it to redeem your nation; you better not fail. This is the Moses syndrome put on hundreds of people. This is not only promoting people to fulfill an impossible task but a very un-biblical way of doing ministry. We do not redeem nations but people and this is done by teaching them all that Jesus has said (Mt.28:18-19).

If we do not succeed does god fail? We are all expendable, God can easily raise up another to do his work. The example we have to this is spoken in Esther by Mordacai “For if you remain completely silent at this time, relief and deliverance will arise for the Jews from another place, but you and your father's house will perish. Yet who knows whether you have come to the kingdom for such a time as this?” (Esther 4:14). Where is God’s word in context in this new cell church movement?

In their topic: Support the women’s ministry. “God is raising up women in a marvellous way in the leadership. In Genesis 3:15 the prophetic word said to the serpent ‘her offspring will crush your head’. The women have the ability to reproduce cells in an unbelievable way” (Pastor Cesar Castellanos in his article Effective Leadership)

I have no idea what this has to do with women discipleship, it has to do with only one man, the Messiah. The seed is about one person coming from one woman only (Luke 1:31 is Isa. 7:14; Gal.3:16). This is an example of how Scripture is misused to promote their own agenda. Jesus fulfilled the Scripture by the cross. It has nothing to do with women today.

Besides the obvious, there are other Scriptures are taken out of their context to make G12's points. "What shall we do that we might work the works of God?" (John 6:28) pick up the call to "make, mature and mobilise disciples" and be thoroughly equipped to rise to a level of significance. (http://www.kt.org  G12 School of Leaders) 

This is a scripture was used by Jesus to rebuke the Pharisees who were in unbelief looking for a sign. He went on to say to "believe on him whom God sent," not to work.

In another article Castellanos repeats this “Jesus taught us this lesson through His own example. He did not deal with people based on their obvious abilities, but according to the potential He knew they had within (Adapted from 'Successful leadership through Groups of 12' by Pastor Cesar Castellanos)

They had potential within or was it given by the Holy Spirit at Pentecost? This is a major flaw in the concept because. The New Testament teaches that we are not to be looking within ourselves. Jesus gave them the authority from himself, it was not according to the potential He knew they had within. They had none, in fact if one looks as Peter they discover that in his own potenetial he failed everytime.

Success means fulfilling the Creation Mandate - “Fill the earth and subdue it.” And this comes with the blessing of God. It is says, Then God blessed them, and God said to them, “Be fruitful and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on the earth.” Genesis 1:28

Again we have the mandate of Dominionism. Are we to do this today after Adam was removed from the garden. Is this taught to the church by apostles? No so why would this be part of their teaching. Kingdom dominionsts believe we are to rule over the earth now without Christ.

The Cell Church in the European Situation Pastor Colin Dye Part one: The New Reformation Many churches in Europe are beginning to look into the Cell Church concept.

Because of the slow dying of church attendance Dye looks to these unhealthy ways to revive the church. In his topic of Revival hot spots: There are some signs of hope. European churches have felt the impact of Reinhard Bonnke’s booklet campaign recording many thousands of decisions for Christ. The Alpha courses have made a huge impact across the world. It is said that more than one million people have passed through Alpha in Britain alone, many of whom have committed to Christ in the process. The ‘times of refreshing’ flowing from the outpouring of the Spirit at Toronto have affected significant churches across Europe. The Pensacola ‘revival’ also has begun a new move of repentance and restoration in Europe. The television ministry of God Digital is broadcasting strong teaching and fuelling the fires of revival across the Continent.”

I suggest anyone take a serious look at AlphaC course that was birthed out of Nicky Gumbel (Holy Trinity Brompton) that was from a Toronto influence in England. Toronto or Pensacola were not revivals but another spirit taking over services making people act abnormally and in contradiction to the fruit of the Spirit and the spiritual gifts. To speak favorably on this shows the lack of discernment and the ideas accepted by these men to acheive ther goals.

Using the example of Augustinian monk by the name of Martin Luther nailed his 95 theses against indulgences to the door of the church in Wittenburg, Germany. In the topic of The priesthood of all believers Dye says The Holy Spirit is giving us new models of church that ensure the whole body of Christ is activated into the work of the ministry.”

“One of the most basic ecclesiological principles of the New Testament is that the Church is the body of Christ. That is, the Church expresses the presence and activity of the Lord. In the same way that your presence is carried by your body so we as the body of Christ carry his presence. And in the same way that your body carries out your activity so we as the body of Christ carry out His work in the world. When Christ wants to work in the world, he uses his body. This is the teaching of Paul’s letter to the Ephesians.

And He Himself gave some to be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, and some pastors and teachers, for the equipping of the saints for the work of ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ Ephesians 4:11-12.

Today God is restoring such a church. The recent apostolic emphasis on the five-fold ministry across the world is producing a new hunger in the body of Christ for a complete re-thinking of how we ‘do’ and ‘be’ church in the world today.

Only through the cells can such disciples be made. The ‘open’ cells in the G12 Model attract new believers and release the members into active ministry.

Lets look at what he has stated carefully. a new model of Church, not from the Bible. Where does the book of Ephesians say such a thing? When Christ wants to work in the world, he uses his body. God can’t work outside the human bodies he has as the church? Is God limited to this? He certainly was able to before the church, why not now? The Eph. 4 passage is explaining that they leadership to equip the church so that we are mature and do not go for every new wind of doctrine that blows through, that would mean we should not go for the G-12 which is a complete re-thinking of how we ‘do’ and ‘be’ church (classic paradigm shift talk). Only through cells can disciples be made! They have gone beyond the Scripture which Paul who wrote Ephesians 4 says not to do: “That you may learn in us not to think beyond what is written.” In other words, if we are to maintain spiritual health and do God’s work his way, the apostle Paul is saying we are not to seek new revelation outside the clear teaching of the Word. And this is certainly something new. While the intent may be good, the principle of discipling may be right, the implementation and Scripture to validate it is not.

The main point is that they are proposing that God restoring such a church. We need to be aware that the recent apostolic emphasis on the five-fold ministry is coming from a group of self appointed apostles which are linked with a whole lot of false prophets. They are mainly dominionist's and have been practicing doctrines of the Latter Rain. Not surprising that Colin Dye has said Jesus is not going to come until the entire church prays “Come, Jesus, Come” (Colin Dye, undated video broadcast on Joshua TV (Amsterdam), Aug. 12, 1998).

On page 20 of Revival Phenomena Colin Dye says on spiritual gifts: "The New Testament may not list every possible gift; and Jesus may send other ones which are not mentioned in Romans 12:3-8; Ephesians 4:7-16 and 1 Corinthians 12:1-11." On p.40: "It seems logical to me, therefore, not to limit the range of his (God's) possible activities just to those which are specifically recorded or exemplified in the scriptures" (book-Revival Phenomena).

Here we have a classic case of going beyond Scripture. Therefore anything supernatural happens any strange manifestation must be accepted as from God because it is no longer able to be tested by the word. What a place to bring the church to live by, no right or wrong. 

                             Under the topic of  A Man of faith:
"Those who want to have a successful ministry must live in the realm of faith. Only through faith is our relationship with God strengthened and we are able to fulfil all our dreams. Faith operates outside our senses. It is born in the heart. Generally, all human beings have the tendency to walk by sight and not by faith. We rely on what we see, forgetting there is a spiritual realm that our eyes don’t see. It does exist and is both real and eternal. Faith connects us to the invisible and eternal world, where God’s government and celestial court is found. Faith moves us out of human limitations and transports us to the threshold of divine glory, where we leave our weakness and feebleness at the feet of the cross in order to be clothed with the invincible strength of the Spirit of God. We leave behind a world of failure and defeat to walk the solid streets of success and prosperity, transform the absurd into something logical, the rotten and despised into something useful and blessed for the world. Abraham only chose one path - the faith path. This opened up to him all the doors of success. He received strength to overcome all obstacles and made a bridge between the possible and the impossible. By faith, he could drink from the springs of life that made him young and vigorous again and he could fly with the wings of the Spirit walking around the celestial city, whose architect and constructor is God himself. He left the blessing for his seed, which is Christ. And Christ extended it to all those who are of the faith, that is to say, to those who have accepted Jesus in a personal way and are living according to the God’s Word.

Are we to fulfill our dreams or God’s will? Faith is not to connect us to an invisible world as word faith teachers teach, it is our heartfelt trust in God and his promises. Neither does faith promise success or prosperity to everyone, otherwise God has lied. Look at Hebrews 11 and see the lives of the faithful that lived impoverished lives because of their dedication.

Abraham's faith is not what made him young or vigorous, nor did he show a  maturity in faith, for he wavered at this promise from God (Remember Hagar Gal.4:22). It was God who promised it and would fulfill it, that it was a unconditional covenant (Heb.6:13).  Lets not forget Sarah had a part to play in this (Heb.11:8). The flamboyant speech on faith that goes beyond what the Bible describes took place does not help his cause.

Citing Genesis 12:2-3 When you obey the Great Commission of Jesus to disciple the nations you step into the blessing of Abraham and he was blessed in all things!

 Scripture tells us Christ has redeemed us from the curse of the law, having become a curse for us (for it is written, “Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree”), that the blessing of Abraham might come upon the Gentiles in Christ Jesus, that we might receive the promise of the Spirit through faith” (Gal 3:13-14 ). If you have Jesus Christ you already have the blessing of Abraham, it is the promise of the Spirit to those who believe. This is not a correct way to prompt people to be more serious to evangelize.

There is also word faith teaching involved among the other unbiblical concepts.

“Abraham being the father of a multitude and we being sons of Abraham, we ought to claim that we are conquering the multitude and confess that they are coming. We must see them coming. Once you know the miracle you want and can see it clearly, you only have to give the word of authority for it to be revealed exactly as you dreamt. Then what we conquer in the spiritual realm can be brought by faith to the natural realm (Pastor Cesar Castellanos in his article Effective Leadership)

Where does the Bible teach this? Clearly no Scripture justifies this, and it gives us insight into what Castellanos actually believes. Claim what we are conquering by faith? Did Abraham do this? This is a typical method practiced in the occult, of seeing first, decreeing it, confessing it and then speaking it into existence to draw it out of this spiritual realm into our world (certainly an influence from Yonggi Cho's visualization ideas). We don’t go into the spiritual realm to make something manifest in the physical, this is taught by the mind sciences. There is nothing in the Bible that either teaches this, nor is able to happen by the method being promoted, it is found practiced in the new age movement.

Dick Bernal of Jubilee Christian Center says,  The Vision God has given Jubilee is to be a lighthouse of good news of our Lord Jesus Christ as we seek to “take our cities for God.” This is right out of the  concept of John Dawson's book Taking our cities for God. So we can see that there are many unhealthy charismatic influences in this cell church movement.

Leading proponent  of the cell church, author Joel Comiskey, who has himself written a complimentary book about G12.  

 3. The division this model is causing: In a very real way, the G12 movement has separated themselves from the cell church movement, claiming to be God’s new wineskin for the last days. Listen to Ralph Neighbour ’s appeal in a paper he submitted to the Cell Church Missions Network in November 2002, “The concept of building a multilevel marketing structure that peaks in the authority of a special Global Apostle with his hand-picked assistants has now come into existence. Bedazzled by the promise of fast track growth for their congregations, pastors are kneeling to kiss the gold rings worn by the Apostles. At the same time, they are severing relationships with fellow cell church workers who are not among the devotees. In many parts of the world, painful reports are coming about pastors who one or two years ago were very intimately involved in helping each other and working together in the cell movements in their cities but who now shun fellowship with others who did not bow before the Apostle’s strategy.”

Before anyone joins in with the G-12 or any other movements like it, I suggest they look into what they are actually practicing and who are their affiliations. Khong (who trained at Dallas Theological Seminary) was fired from his church in 1986 and began Faith Community Baptist Church basing it on the Yonggi Cho cell model.   Lawrence Khong is now part of Wagner’s leadership, so this movement is one step away to from Peter Wagner’s false apostolic government. In fact this strategy of cell church is being used by many of the apostles to set up their church government since it is  a easier means of control. Does this mean a cell church model of meeting in homes is wrong? Of course not, yet we should be aware of how it is being implemented and what is it associated to.

While people can have zeal to accomplish what God asks it is just as important to do it God’s way based on the Scripture. There is so much more that could be said but this should be sufficient for those who want to enter this cell church model to beware, best to look into these new movements before one commits to them.  


© 2009 No portion of this site is to be copied or used unless kept in its original format- the way it appears. Articles can be reproduced in portions for ones personal use. Any other use is to have the permission of  Let Us Reason Ministries first. Thank You.

We always appreciate hearing  from those of you that have benefited by the articles on our website. We love hearing the testimonies and praise reports. We are here to help those who have questions on Bible doctrine, new teachings and movements.  Unfortunately we cannot answer every email. Our time is valuable just as yours is, please keep in mind, we only have time to answer sincere inquiries from those who need help. For those who have another point of view, we will answer emails that want to engage in authentic dialogue, not in arguments. We will use discretion in answering any letters. 

  Let Us Reason Ministries

We thank you for your support in our ministry